US nuclear power: A dying industry or growing powerhouse?

By Matthew Rusling
0 CommentsPrint E-mail Xinhua, February 20, 2010
Adjust font size:

Critics have blasted U.S. President Barack Obama's plan to provide loan guarantees for the construction of two new nuclear reactors, labeling the nuclear industry unsustainable and saying it is in need of life support from Washington.

But supporters say the industry is poised to grow and note that it has support among the U.S. public, Congress and the Obama administration.

Obama announced on Tuesday that the government would provide 8 billion U.S. dollars in federal loan guarantees to help build two nuclear reactors in Georgia. That is just the beginning, he said, adding that he aims to build a new generation of nuclear power plants.

"We are extremely disappointed in Obama because basically he's playing politics rather than doing what's right for the American people," said Jim Riccio, nuclear policy analyst at Greenpeace, an environmental organization.

Riccio contended that Obama is pandering to the nuclear industry in order to gain support for a climate bill that is languishing in Congress.

"It's a sop. Obama can't get climate legislation passed so he's trying to marry two red-headed step children together and bill it as some sort of a program," he said.

While the nuclear industry contends the plan marks a renaissance, Riccio countered that it is nothing of the sort.

"You don't have the industry moving forward here," he said, "You have the industry coming to Washington with hat in hand saying 'these are too expensive to build unless you back them.'"

Opponents note that both the Government Accountability Office and the Congressional Budget Office estimated a 50 percent of default risk for nuclear power plants. And a half dozen large investment banks told the Energy Department in 2007 that they would not take on any more financial risk for nuclear power.

Paul Walker, director of security and sustainability at Global Green USA, an environmental group founded by former Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev, dismissed any possibility of a nuclear renaissance, even though the nuclear energy industry promotes itself as a response to global warming.

The three main barriers are high costs, safety concerns and the possibility of weapons proliferation, he said.

Walker said the industry is unlikely to expand beyond the current U.S. levels -- the United States has more than 100 nuclear power plants -- adding that plant numbers could decline because of the decade-long process for building new facilities.

But the nuclear power industry disagrees.

"The nuclear renaissance is going on already," said Tom Kauffman, spokesman for the Nuclear Energy Institute, a policy organization for the industry.

He pointed out that more than 50 plants are under construction worldwide, although there are no new plant projects in the United States.

But that will change, he added.

"What this was for us was a profound endorsement by President Obama and Energy Secretary Chu of nuclear energy and he stated clearly... that he believes we need to develop a new generation of nuclear power plants," he said of Obama's announcement on Tuesday.

Support in Congress is growing and the Georgia plants are just the beginning, Kauffman said, noting that Obama has asked Congress to triple funding for the nuclear loan guarantee program to 54 billion U.S. dollars.

Kauffman argues that the use of nuclear energy is the only way the U.S.can meet its energy and environmental goals, as the demand for electricity will continue to increase by around 1 percent per year, according to government figures.

Along with other energy sources, solar and hydro for example, nuclear energy will satisfy U.S. demand for clean energy, he said.

Supporters of nuclear power say the technology is safe, and that past accidents such as Chernobyl -- the result of major design deficiencies, violation of operating procedures and the absence of a safety culture, according to the World Nuclear Association -- are unlikely to reoccur today.

Charles D. Ferguson, president of the Federation of American Scientists, said the U.S. nuclear industry, with 104 reactors, is not dying but may not grow either.

"After all, the U.S. operates the most reactors of any country," he said.

"However, there are concerns about continued growth. Some loan guarantee money for a couple of plants will do little to stimulate new substantial growth."

Still, an increase in the number of nuclear power plants could create a windfall of high paying jobs for skilled blue collar workers, such as welders, electricians and fire inspectors, he said.

The U.S. has not seen a new nuclear power plant for three decades, after the calamitous Three Mile Island accident spurred panic among the U.S. public.

And many Americans appear to have forgotten the incident. A Gallup poll last year found that support for nuclear energy has reached a new high, with 59 percent of respondents favoring its use.

But Greenpeace's Riccio said the public has expressed its opposition at the state, local and national level, and noted a number of green and other organizations oppose nuclear power, such as Friends of the Earth and the Union of Concerned Scientists.

Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comments

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 久久精品国产亚洲AV蜜臀色欲| 亚洲精品欧美精品中文字幕| 黄色免费短视频| 国产高清精品一区| 一个男的操一个女的| 放荡的女按摩师2| 久久精品国产99久久99久久久| 欧美三日本三级少妇三级久久| 亚洲精品午夜国产va久久成人| www..99557c..com| 日本pissjapantv厕所自| 九色综合狠狠综合久久| 欧美国产亚洲日韩在线二区 | 国产真实乱子伦视频播放| 91亚洲欧美国产制服动漫| 天天操天天操天天操| 久久婷婷五月综合97色直播| 男人扒开女人的腿做爽爽视频| 啊灬啊别停灬用力啊公阅读| 调教15小男生gay脱裤子| 国产成人涩涩涩视频在线观看| xxxxx日韩| 精品国产VA久久久久久久冰| 国产在线一卡二卡| 亚洲h在线观看| 国产精品女在线观看| 91精品成人福利在线播放| 天天躁日日躁狠狠躁av中文| 久久国产精品亚洲一区二区| 果冻传媒电影在线| 亚洲区视频在线观看| 欧美猛交xxxxx| 可以直接看的毛片| 色噜噜狠狠一区二区三区果冻| 国产午夜福利片| 黄网在线免费看| 国产成人无码区免费A∨视频网站| 亚洲性图第一页| 国产白嫩美女在线观看| 天天成人综合网| 国产浮力影院在线地址|