Order is preferable over chaos in Middle East

By Sumantra Maitra
0 Comment(s)Print E-mail China.org.cn, January 6, 2018
Adjust font size:

Will we see an Iranian revolution in 2018? This topic is not a theoretical discussion but what regime-change fanatics are starting their articles with. Iran has witnessed a week of violence, and the protest seems to stem from Iranian economic stagnation. Cries of death to the dictator are in the air, which means death to Iran's supreme leader, which is a capital offence under Iranian law.

Government supporters and opponents march across Iran. [Screenshot]

Over 20 people are already dead, and Iran's leaders, both moderate and hardliners, are somewhat flabbergasted as to what the next move might be, as no one expected this backlash. Some of them are darkly hinting at a plausible Saudi effort to destabilize the regime by providing funding to Sunni insurgent groups.

This is a tricky situation for the international community, which can be observed from the silence from Iranian partners like India and the EU. Not a single word has come out of the EU bureaucracy, or from traditional regional partners like India. But it also is a tricky situation for traditional Iranian opponents. The Israeli PM, while being superficially supportive, is asking his ministers to pipe down on actively opposing Tehran's government. The British and American governments are also not actively doing anything other than releasing rhetorical attacks on Iran and stating that Iran needs to care about the "democratic aspirations" of its protestors. The reason might be due to the simple fact that everyone is wary of another Middle Eastern spring, this time involving a major military power in Persia – it is a positively nightmarish scenario.

Order is better than chaos and anarchy, that's the fundamental logic behind foreign policy. Unlike in 2009, where actual grassroots level protests rocked the country, this time it is sporadic, and more violent. In fact according to Iran experts on Twitter, the potential of violence is actually scaring off the protesters from a decade back. No one wants to see another Libya or Syria in their country, not even the ones who are arguably repressed.

That's not noticeable amongst the twitter experts and social media commentators however. But given the experience of Iraq, there are questions which need to be answered before anyone can suggest any policy course. Who are the people pushing for a Persian spring in Iran that are based in U.S. and Europe, and how much does the foreign based expat Iranian community's aspirations reflect the Iranians who are in the country? Iran is after all an electoral democracy, that's more than could be said about any Sunni powers in the region. Iranian expats, especially those who have lived for more than two generations abroad will have a warped view of realities on the ground, and may view the situation from their own perspectives, which might or might not be beneficial for the national interests of other powers. Imagine the arguments from Iraqi expats about toppling Saddam, or by Libyan expats about Gaddafi. How's that working out?

Secondly, everyone should be careful before they argue about interfering in the sovereign matters of another power. Where does this stop? Tomorrow, if Iran funds Occupy Wall Street or Black Lives matters, there won't be any logical counter arguments against such. There's a reason Westphalian nation states agreed to the principle of non-interference in the sovereignty of other states. It is because the concept is like nuclear deterrence, a sort of Mutually Assured Destruction.

One therefore might be very careful of what one wishes for, especially from a Western foreign policy perspective. Regimes might be brutal, but as long as they are providing stability and order, they are better than complete chaos. Iran, and Iran funded Shia militias are all over the region from Yemen to Syria. The Iranian government still enjoys a majority of support from the people of Iran, who more importantly than not, do not want any foreign interference. The previous "springs" also didn't result in liberal outcomes; from Iraq, to Egypt, Bahrain, Libya and Syria, and there's no evidence to believe this time it will be any different. The prudent policy is therefore to wait and observe, instead of pouring fuel on the fire. 

Sumantra Maitra is a columnist with China.org.cn. For more information please visit:

http://www.ccgp-fushun.com/opinion/SumantraMaitra.htm

Opinion articles reflect the views of their authors only, not necessarily those of China.org.cn.

Follow China.org.cn on Twitter and Facebook to join the conversation.
ChinaNews App Download
Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comment(s)

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Enter the words you see:   
    Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 老师办公室被吃奶好爽在线观看| 亚洲午夜久久久精品影院| 韩国伦理s级在线| 国产第一页屁屁影院| 91网站网址最新| 天天天天躁天天爱天天碰2018| 中文字幕丰满孑伦| 欧美日韩精品一区二区三区不卡 | 国产精品高清一区二区人妖| chinese18国产高清| 尤物精品视频一区二区三区| 久久9精品久久久| 欧美重口另类在线播放二区 | 巨大欧美黑人xxxxbbbb| 中文字幕日韩精品无码内射| 日本强伦姧人妻一区二区| 亚洲第一页视频| 男女做性无遮挡免费视频| 和僧侣的交行之夜樱花| 色在线亚洲视频www| 国产亚洲精品精品国产亚洲综合| 91精品欧美产品免费观看| 天堂а在线中文在线新版| 一区二区三区在线|欧| 成人区人妻精品一区二区不卡网站| 亚洲av无码成人精品区狼人影院| 欧美性xxxxx极品娇小| 全日本爽视频在线| 高清午夜看片a福利在线观看琪琪 高清国产av一区二区三区 | 青青草综合在线| 国产在线观看一区二区三区四区| 成人免费福利视频| 国产日产在线观看| 好男人官网在线播放| 国产欧美一区二区| 欧美一级特黄乱妇高清视频| 国产的一级毛片完整| 日韩欧美一区二区三区免费看| 国产精品va欧美精品| 日本在线xxxx| 国产成人精品午夜二三区 |