Is destroying statues a rightful way of correcting historical wrongs?

By Earl Bousquet
0 Comment(s)Print E-mail China.org.cn, August 25, 2017
Adjust font size:

Slavery was the greatest crime against humanity, and racism remains its most damning legacy. The growing outrage across America against the resurgence of racist ebullience in states built on the blood and sweat of slaves must therefore be applauded.

However, this does raise the question as to how far tearing down statues of pro-slavery villains presented as saints really goes in changing the living effects of their racist legacy?

The removal across America of statues honoring men like confederate General Robert F. Lee is akin to a similar action against statues of Cecil Rhodes, the original architect of apartheid laws in South Africa and creator of the old racist Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe).

Following student protests, a Rhodes statue was pulled down at South Africa’s University of Cape Town (UCT) in April 2015; and Rhodes University in Grahamstown was forced to consider a renaming exercise.

However, at Britain’s Oxford University students who voted for a similar removal were overruled in January 2016 by the university's administration after the Rhodes’ estate threatened to withdraw annual support worth over £300 million.

The role of slavery in the history of major American universities has been unfolding lately. Having been found guilty by the jury of public opinion of being on the wrong side of history, the related institutions are now hurrying to establish political correctness.

However, this raises a question of how best can the increasing numbers of U.S. universities mired in slavery best repair that sordid history today? By merely giving token scholarships to selected descendants of African American or Caribbean slaves in affected communities, states or nations, for instance?

And what of today’s Rhodes scholars around the world? Should each be ashamed for their academic achievements being financed by funds from a noted racist?

Extremists of various persuasions take pride in displaying destruction of everything from giant religious statues to UNESCO-recognized World Heritage Sites, to museum collections of objects thousands of years old. Should the world ever even begin to consider accepting that such precious historical works of art can be destroyed based on rival religious or cultural grounds?

Monuments to racism and apartheid are coming down quickly today in the U.S. and such calls are also growing in popularity elsewhere

It’s yet to be seen how destruction or removal of statues will contribute to equal access for black students to attend mainly white “Ivy League” universities funded by or named after those historical architects of racism, whether in the U.S. or Southern Africa.

How far and fast nations or advocates go about correcting historical wrongs or rewriting fake history depends on several factors. Some critics see destruction of statues as “editing history,” others as mere symbolism that does not actually change reality. Fact is, though, not everything considered bad must be destroyed and/or consigned to the scrapheap of history.

Slavery was the worst crime against humanity, but it cannot be simply wished or washed away because it was so atrocious.

American supporters of racism and defenders of slavery idolize confederate leaders’ statues because they believe in what they represented. They, too, will fight on, to not only preserve those statues in areas where they are still protected by law, but also to replace them when historical timing next permits.

Some critics suggest that instead of destroying works of art for political reasons, they can be relocated to a place where the age-old lies associated with them can be exposed with facts. Indeed, instances abound where symbols of a sordid past have been preserved and maintained to show and teach lessons from the experiences they represent.

For example, the Smithsonian Institute in Washington recently unveiled the Museum of African American History, where all Americans can see and learn some aspects of slavery in the U.S. Pieces of art destroyed in China during the Cultural Revolution are being painstakingly restored.

Dungeons on African coasts where captured men, women and children were held for shipping into slavery remain open today as popular tourism exhibits.

Robben Island, where Nelson Mandela was imprisoned and South African freedom fighters were tortured, was not shut down after the end of Apartheid as a disgraceful location of national shame, but is instead today a popular tourist attraction.

Americans can best decide how to demonstrate their contempt for and rejection of racism’s living legacy and what to do about monuments dedicated to defenders of slavery.

I didn't enjoy watching Saddam Hussein's statue being pulled down in Baghdad by invading American troops, Muammar Gadaffi’s busts being destroyed across Libya after his fall, Lenin’s monuments being torn down in the Ukraine, or of Cuba’s Jose Marti’s bust being vandalized in Venezuela recently.

Each (destroyed statue) represents a permanent figure in the history of each country – and tearing down or defacing it, cannot erase that history.

I will not go to war with anyone who feels an unfair weight of history has been lifted off their backs by the destruction of offensive statues. However, I would risk a battle trying to find out to what extent that psychological weight-loss becomes a qualitative, real-life game-changer today.

Earl Bousquet is a contributor to china.org.cn, editor-at-large of The Diplomatic Courier and author of an online regional newspaper column entitled Chronicles of a Chronic Caribbean Chronicler.

Opinion articles reflect the views of their authors, not necessarily those of China.org.cn.

Follow China.org.cn on Twitter and Facebook to join the conversation.
ChinaNews App Download
Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comment(s)

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Enter the words you see:   
    Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 宝贝过来趴好张开腿让我看看| 欧美A∨在线观看| 国产94在线传媒麻豆免费观看| 色综合色综合久久综合频道| 在线观看免费av网站| 一级成人a做片免费| 日本三级韩国三级美三级91 | 国产精品免费久久久久影院| 人妻少妇精品视频专区| 老师…好紧开裆蕾丝内裤| 国产女主播喷水视频在线观看| 毛片基地看看成人免费| 无码人妻一区二区三区免费n鬼沢| 亚洲一区二区三区深夜天堂| 永久免费视频网站在线观看| 免费在线视频一区| 美女张开腿给男人桶| 国产亚洲女在线精品| 黑人巨大两根一起挤进欧美| 国产精品久久久久久久久久久不卡| 97色婷婷成人综合在线观看| 天天躁夜夜躁狠狠躁2021西西 | 国产福利影院在线观看| 91亚洲一区二区在线观看不卡| 天堂在线中文字幕| 一二三四日本高清社区5| 成人午夜视频在线播放| 丰满少妇人妻无码专区| 日本在线电影一区二区三区| 久久精品青草社区| 机机对机机的30分钟免费软件| 亚洲国产成AV人天堂无码| 欧美日韩视频在线第一区| 亚洲电影中文字幕| 波多野结衣丝袜诱惑| 人人妻人人添人人爽日韩欧美| 男女啪啪免费体验区| 免费在线观看h| 男的把j伸进女人p图片动态 | 911色主站性欧美| 国产高清一区二区三区 |