Media must not hold 'kangaroo courts'

By Ku Ma
0 Comment(s)Print E-mail China Daily, March 8, 2013
Adjust font size:

The death of Haobo, a two-month-old baby, in Changchun, Jilin province, is an enormous tragedy for his family as well as the entire society.

On Monday, it was reported that the baby had gone missing along with the car, a Toyota RAV4, that his father surnamed Xu had left him in with the key in the ignition when he went inside the supermarket where he worked for a few minutes.

Xu called the local radio station and police both for help. Local media outlets and social media messages mobilized thousands of the city's taxi drivers and residents to join about 3,500 police officers in the search for the baby. On Tuesday evening, Zhou Xijun, 48, surrendered to police saying he had strangled the baby and buried the body in snow near a countryside road after stealing the car.

Netizens, including many celebrities, have lashed out at the suspect. Many microbloggers have demanded that "the murderer be punished with lingchi" (dismembering the body), one of the cruelest ways of putting a person to death.

The public furor over the murder of the baby is understandable but, more importantly, the incident should teach society to take measures to avoid a similar tragedy rather than only baying for the murderer's blood.

This also is the time to reflect on the media's role as investigators into a crime. The debate on media-justice relationship during a trial is old. Thanks to social media, nowadays many criminal cases are "exposed" in the early stages of investigation. Criminal cases, especially those involving vulnerable people who can easily touch people's nerves, are a favorite of the press.

In the Changchun case, some newspapers have even insisted that the manhunt mobilized by the media reports and social networks "showed full responsibility for life". But since the suspect turned himself in and no details are yet known, such a claim is self-righteous.

Media reports on criminal investigations, in most cases, are a double-edged sword. On one hand, people have the right to know if some crimes threaten public safety, and some reports on criminal investigation indeed help supervise police and prevent travesty of justice. On the other hand, misleading reports on criminal investigations can harm police investigation or provide clues to suspects to escape, or even prompt them to target hostages or witnesses for revenge.

If the media insist such sensationalization of investigations into crimes is for good, the possibility of a similar tragedy occurring cannot be ruled out.

Moreover, even at the investigation stage, social networks are agog with calls for handing Zhou the death penalty. It's absolutely true that every criminal deserves punishment according to law. But even before the trial has started, social as well as many traditional media have posted photographs of the suspect with captions saying "this is the man who killed the two-month old baby". Such reporting is tantamount to delivering justice through trial by the media and will not bring any comfort to the family of the victim.

Many netizens have blamed Chinese people's inherent nature for the Changchun crime. To show how different people in other countries are and to prove their point they have cited the example of a carjacker in the United States, who called police to tell them where he had abandoned a car that he had stolen after he found a baby in it.

The New York Post did report the incident but told a contrasting story: the parents didn't call the local media after their baby and car had gone missing. Besides, the local media didn't sensationalize the case of the missing child. So contrary to what Chinese netizens claim, the "similar" incidents are not about human nature. Instead, they expose the gap in Chinese and US people's awareness of the rule of law.

According to the US justice census bureau, 5.8 million Americans aged 12 years and above fall victim to violence, which means 225 out of every 10,000 Americans are victims of violence. Reuters has reported that the number of murders and manslaughters in the US was 13,800 in 2011.

Public safety in China is a big concern, as the case of serial killer Zhou Kehua showed last year. But in general, violent cases have dropped to the lowest point in a decade, according to a blue paper of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. For instance, gun-related crimes dropped from more than 5,000 in 2000 to just more than 500 in 2011.

Compared with the US and other developed countries, China still has a lot of room for improvement when it comes to the rule of law. And Chinese society, which includes individuals, media and social networks, needs to raise its awareness of the rule of law.

In 1998, the United Kingdom formed a Policing and Reducing Crime Unit, which published its research, The Effective Use of the Media in Serious Crime Investigations, a year later that can be seen as a guide to reporting crime. In Germany, the media follows a basic principle not to name a suspect until he pleads or is found guilty and sentenced. In 1987, Japanese lawyer association said media reporting should strike a balance between the public's right to know and exercising caution on reporting on criminal investigations.

In China, too, crime reporting should follow certain rules, and traditional and new media should avoid inappropriate reporting that may complicate criminal cases. They also should stop trying suspects in "media courts" because that is the job of the judicial department.

Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comment(s)

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Enter the words you see:   
    Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 一区二区三区国产最好的精华液 | 午夜黄色一级片| 黑巨人与欧美精品一区| 国产精品盗摄一区二区在线 | 欧美专区日韩专区| 亚洲熟妇av一区二区三区宅男| 粉嫩极品国产在线观看| 四虎国产欧美成人影院| 被民工蹂躏的雯雅婷| 国产女人在线观看| 日本国产在线视频| 国产精品免费_区二区三区观看| 91精品在线看| 在线观看国产一区| chinesehd国产刺激对白| 好男人资源在线手机免费| 两个小姨子在线观看| 成年女性特黄午夜视频免费看| 久久亚洲AV午夜福利精品一区| 日韩欧美高清视频| 亚欧洲精品在线视频免费观看| 欧美三级中文字幕在线观看| 亚洲国产综合人成综合网站00| 欧美精品亚洲精品日韩专区| 亚洲综合色成在线播放| 男人和女人在床做黄的网站| 免费床戏全程无遮挡在线观看| 精品国产免费观看一区| 啄木乌欧美一区二区三区| 老八吃屎奥利给原视频带声音的| 国产丰满岳乱妇在线观看| 超级乱淫岳最新章节目录| 国产人妖cdmagnet| 韩国亚洲伊人久久综合影院| 国产性生交xxxxx免费| 黄色毛片小视频| 国产成A人亚洲精V品无码性色| 麻豆高清区在线| 国产小视频在线观看网站| 麻豆精品一区二区三区免费| 国产成人www|