Romney tests China policy

By David Shambaugh
0 Comment(s)Print E-mail China Daily, August 8, 2012
Adjust font size:

As theUS presidential election enters its final three months, Republican challenger Mitt Romney is beginning to define his foreign policy beliefs. Until recently, Romney had limited his comments on foreign policy to a combination of tough talk and platitudes, but now he is beginning to flesh out more detailed policies on different foreign issues and parts of the world.

The official website of Romney's campaign recently announced the assemblage of a large foreign policy advisory team and a series of policy statements on national security and different parts of the world. Romney's foreign policy advisers are largely a collection of recycled George W. Bush administration officials.

Based on the official website's description, what might a Romney administration China policy look like? First, it is worth noting that on China and Asia, as with virtually every other part of the world, one consistent theme is pervasive: increasing American military strength.

On national defense, for example, the Romney platform takes the administration of US President Barack Obama to task for slashing military spending and neglecting weapons' modernization, hinting that "weakness invites aggression". This suggests defense should somehow be exempt from budget cuts in the current fiscal austerity climate.

It is not that Romney wants to insulate and freeze the force from cuts, but he seeks to actually "grow" the military - adding nearly 50 ships to the navy and doubling the number of fighter squadrons.

This military-first mindset underlies the way the Romney team seems to approach every other foreign policy challenge - from Afghanistan and Iran to China and Russia. In each case, it is argued that American military strength will deter aggression. This simplistic zero-sum mindset is a throwback to the Cold War and is no substitute for nuanced policies to deal with today's complex challenges.

With respect to China, the Romney policy places a robust military and security presence first. While it does claim that "Our objective is not to build an anti-China coalition" and leaves the door open to Beijing for "becoming a responsible partner in the international system", the position paper predominantly takes a deterrence tack, emphasizing a potential China threat that must be met with US strength:

"In the face of China's accelerated military build-up, the United States and our allies must maintain appropriate military capabilities to discourage any aggressive or coercive behavior by China against its neighbors."

Romney's position proceeds from the premise that China seeks to dominate Asia and, concomitantly, exclude the US from the region: "China must be discouraged from attempting to intimidate or dominate neighboring states. If the present Chinese regime is permitted to establish itself as the preponderant power in the Western Pacific it could close off large parts of the region to cooperative relations with the United States and the West and dim hope that economic opportunity and democratic freedom will continue to flourish across East Asia."

The policy statement also more than hints that Romney would authorize sale of advanced F-16 C/Ds to Taiwan (something the Obama administration has thus far eschewed) when it argues: "The Department of Defense should reconsider recent decisions not to sell top-of-the-line equipment to our closest Asian allies. We should be coordinating with Taiwan to determine its military needs and supplying them with adequate aircraft and other military platforms."

The remainder of the China-Asia section, though, is not dissimilar from the "strategic pivot" policies that the Obama administration is already implementing in the region, if not more robust. One might describe it as "Pivot Plus".

Indeed, the Obama pivot finds its origins in the "strategic hedging" policies of the Bush administration. It is also no accident that the two lead members of Romney's Asia advisory team - Aaron Friedberg of Princeton University and Evan Feigenbaum of Carnegie Endowment for International Peace - served as senior officials in the Bush administration and were among the masterminds of the strategic hedging policy.

On other parts of the world, such as Africa, the Romney vision labels China a "global competitor". Romney has also argued on the campaign trail that he would "label China a currency manipulator on Day 1". The Romney campaign's statement on China does include a prominent role for human rights - not only concerning political dissent, but a broader conceptualization of promoting civil society. Indeed, assertive promotion of democracy pops up in the discussion of Latin America, Asia, Russia and the Middle East.

While this is largely drawn from official campaign sources, and it must be remembered that tough campaign assertions often fall by the wayside when a candidate enters office and confronts reality, the Romney campaign's description of China does offer an important prism into the thinking of Romney's advisers - if not Romney himself.

Much of it is tough talk, not dissimilar from the election-year rhetoric of Bush in 2000. But when taken together with the Obama administration's pivot to Asia, which is primarily motivated by the strategic uncertainties associated with the rise of China, relations between China and the US could be headed into contentious waters in the years ahead.

The writer is professor of Political Science & International Affairs and Director of the China Policy Program at George Washington University.

 

Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comment(s)

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Enter the words you see:   
    Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 沦为色老头狂欲的雅婷| 两个小姨子韩国电影| 老子午夜我不卡理论影院| 在线二区人妖系列| 三中文乱码视频| 日本人与黑人xxxx| 亚洲精品tv久久久久久久久| 风流艳妇在线观看| 国产精品久久久久乳精品爆| 中国一级黄色片子| 日本大片在线看黄a∨免费| 免费高清日本中文| 黄瓜视频官网下载免费版| 国产精品理论电影| 99久久免费国产精品| 好吊妞欧美视频免费高清| 久别的草原电视剧免费观看| 欧美成人鲁丝片在线观看| 亚洲香蕉久久一区二区| 资源在线www天堂| 字幕网免费高清观看电影| 久久99国产乱子伦精品免费| 日韩人妻系列无码专区| 午夜精品一区二区三区免费视频 | 成人看免费一级毛片| 久久久久琪琪去精品色无码| 日韩欧美国产综合| 亚洲va在线∨a天堂va欧美va| 狠狠色丁香婷婷久久综合蜜芽 | 国产美女a做受大片观看| 一级做a爰片久久免费| 无码AV免费毛片一区二区| 久久久久人妻精品一区三寸蜜桃| 欧美不卡一区二区三区免| 亚洲成aⅴ人片| 男女激情边摸边做边吃奶在线观看| 国产乱人伦精品一区二区在线观看| 手机在线看片你懂的| 好男人在线社区www在线视频一| 久久国产欧美日韩精品| 明星ai人脸替换造梦在线播放|