China can't go American

By David Lundquist
0 Comment(s)Print E-mail Beijing Review, February 10, 2012
Adjust font size:

In the terms I've just described, the hopes of China's middle class will be checked by the country's physical and environmental limits. It's a nice thought, but China routinely proves that it can push those limits with the sheer mass of its population. Every Chinese Lunar New Year's chunyun—travels back home for the traditional festival, every National Holiday week of tourism, and every Friday night on Beijing's highways gives us reason to consider the determination of Chinese citizens. Like Americans, they don't easily accept defeat or relegation to fixed social strata. Have-nots want to be haves. For Americans like me, that has come to mean a sort of material plenitude courtesy of Wal-Mart and similar retailers. For Chinese the last few decades, this determination has meant nights standing on a train, just to be home for the holidays. Soon, though, they will come to expect what Americans enjoy, or dare I say, suffer from, material excess, often as a symbol of status.

This, I wish to suggest, cannot be comfortably borne by China's environment and society. There is another model, as I've said already: the European model, in which quality of life is much less a material notion. To oversimplify somewhat, European culture stresses three major points: health, not wealth; stability, not adventure; and a fair-shake society, not a rat race.

To what extent can China adopt this? It's not fully clear. Americans and Chinese can be quite fond of the rat race, at least preferring it to the humdrum pace of European life. Second, like Americans, Chinese attitudes reflect a tolerance for wealth gaps that Western European countries have paired substantially in the post-war era. And in an era of enormous economic transformation, "I've got my health" will be little comfort to Chinese who notice their neighbors buying second homes by the seashore or sending their children abroad for university or even high school and middle school.

What, then, are China's planners to do? My best estimate is that, as with many things, great transformation will not be accomplished through just carrots or sticks, but through a national commitment to avoiding the Americanization of parts of Chinese consumer society. Such an effort would likely include the popularization or even glamorization of sustainable living. Public transport and better, smarter urban design, of course, but also a linking of China's environmental quality to the survival of its many natural and cultural treasures. Crucially, it's here that rising living standards and middle-class consciousness can be exploited. Materially satisfied Chinese are perhaps better able to appreciate the lost mystique of a Taishan Mountain despoiled by empty water bottles and half-gnawed ears of corn.

Skeptical that this can be done? You have reason to be. Chinese airlines, for example, don't even offer customers carbon-offsets sold by third-parties, citing lack of demand. Furthermore, the just-made-it crowd in China, having left behind their bicycles behind in the countryside or college, won't take easily to a slick single-speed and a chance to risk death in traffic during the daily commute.

We shouldn't expect it to be easy, since large national transformations aren't. The United States has never quite taken to the metric system, and most developed nations are helpless to right their entitlement and demographic problems. I have not much in the way of solutions to add here, and I am tempted to resolve only to highlight the gravity of the situation. Perhaps this frame will provide a fresh perspective.

The author is an American teaching Western philosophy at Tsinghua University in Beijing.

   Previous   1   2  


Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comment(s)

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: www.henhenai| 久久国产精品99国产精| 男女下面无遮挡一进一出| 国产一区二区三区免费在线观看| 国产亚洲国产bv网站在线| 国产精彩视频在线观看| a级毛片免费观看在线播放| 成人h在线播放| 久久99热66这里只有精品一| 日韩欧美福利视频| 亚洲乱码无码永久不卡在线| 欧美高清在线精品一区| 人妻内射一区二区在线视频| 精品乱码一区二区三区在线| 四虎国产精品永久免费网址| 西西人体午夜视频| 国产在线拍偷自揄拍无码| 国产人与动zozo| 国产激情视频网站| 男女一进一出抽搐免费视频 | 巨胸喷奶水www永久免费| 国产精欧美一区二区三区| 91精品成人福利在线播放| 在线视频免费国产成人| a级片在线观看视频| 天天色综合天天| jux662正在播放三浦惠理子| 小莹与翁回乡下欢爱姿势| 三级黄在线观看| 成人Av无码一区二区三区| 中文字幕久久久久一区| 手机国产乱子伦精品视频| 久久91精品国产一区二区| 日日夜夜精品免费视频| 久久久久国产精品免费网站| 日本人的色道www免费一区| 久久久久亚洲av成人无码| 日本一区二区三区久久| 久久久久777777人人人视频| 最新夫妇交换乱的中文字幕| 亚1州区2区三区4区产品|