Nuke arms save humanity from itself

By Sergei Karaganov
0 CommentsPrint E-mail China Daily, May 7, 2010
Adjust font size:

Nuclear deterrence - a threat to kill hundreds of thousands or millions of people - is a concept that does not fit into traditional morals. Yet it has worked, preventing catastrophic wars while making people more civilized and cautious. When one pole of nuclear deterrence weakened because of Russia's political decline in the 1990s, the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) committed aggression against Yugoslavia. Now that Russia has restored its capability, such a move would be unthinkable. After Yugoslavia, there was an unprovoked attack on Iraq.

In a nearly perfect world, Russia and the US would not need large nuclear stockpiles. But cutting nuclear weapons to a bare minimum in the current conditions would give a big advantage to small nuclear powers, which will see their nuclear potential gain near-parity with larger states.

Moreover, reducing nuclear weapons to a minimum might theoretically enhance the usefulness of missile-defense systems and their destabilizing role. And even non-strategic missile-defense systems, the deployment of which might be useful, will be questioned.

If stockpiles of tactical nuclear weapons are reduced, as some US, European, and Russian experts have proposed, the opponents of Russia's ongoing military reform will have even more reason to object to the reconfiguration of the country's conventional armed forces away from confrontation with NATO toward a flexible-response capability vis--vis other threats.

Similarly, if the US withdraws its largely nominal tactical nuclear weapons from Europe, US-Europe strategic ties would weaken. Many Europeans, above all in the new NATO member states, would then demand more protection from the mythical Russian leviathan.

The world community seems to be losing its strategic bearings. Instead of focusing on the real problem, namely the increasingly unstable international order, it is trying to apply Cold War-era concepts of disarmament. At best, these are marginally useful; more often, they are harmful in today's circumstances.

What is most needed nowadays is clear thinking about how to live with an expanding club of nuclear states while keeping the world relatively stable. To this end, the two great nuclear powers need a coordinated deterrence policy towards new nuclear states.

Simultaneously, they should offer guarantees to non-nuclear states that might feel insecure. In the first place, it is necessary to fill the increasing security vacuum in the Middle East. China, the world's rising strategic player, might join this policy.

Arms-control talks are mostly needed for rendering national arsenals more transparent, and for building confidence between the great powers. That is all there is to their usefulness.

So, instead of mimicking Cold War-era treaties, it is necessary to launch an international discussion on the role of military force and nuclear weapons in the world as it is now evolving. We might then eventually recognize that eliminating nuclear weapons is not just a myth, but a harmful myth, and that nuclear weapons are a useful asset that has saved, and may continue to save, humanity from itself.

The author is dean of the School of World Economics and Foreign Affairs at Moscow State University - Higher School of Economics.

   Previous   1   2  


Print E-mail Bookmark and Share

Go to Forum >>0 Comments

No comments.

Add your comments...

  • User Name Required
  • Your Comment
  • Racist, abusive and off-topic comments may be removed by the moderator.
Send your storiesGet more from China.org.cnMobileRSSNewsletter
主站蜘蛛池模板: 亚洲欧洲日产国码av系列天堂| 国产呻吟久久久久久久92| 一个人看的免费高清视频www| 日本亚洲色大成网站www久久| 亚洲av第一网站久章草| 欧美日韩电影在线观看| 伊人久久大香线蕉免费视频| 精品日本一区二区三区在线观看 | 国产手机精品一区二区| 18禁男女爽爽爽午夜网站免费| 大学生初次破苞免费视频| 一卡2卡3卡4卡免费高清| 成都4片p高清视频| 亚洲成年人电影在线观看| 特级毛片a级毛片免费播放| 国产在线精品一区二区在线看 | 亚洲人成777| 欧美成人免费全部色播| 亚洲欧美日韩国产精品久久| 玖玖在线资源站| 免费大片黄在线观看| 精品国产自在久久| 午夜视频在线观看一区二区| 老师~你的技术真好好大| 国产一级特黄a大片免费| 足本玉蒲团在线观看| 国产在线爱做人成小视频| 91频在线观看免费大全| 国产日韩精品视频| 久久亚洲精品专区蓝色区| 国产毛片女人18水多| 天天久久影视色香综合网| 国产精品vⅰdeoXXXX国产| 2021国产麻豆剧传媒仙踪林 | 99视频在线免费| 天堂一区二区三区精品| xx00动态图| 好大好深好猛好爽视频免费| www.四虎影视| 天天色天天操综合网| chinese乱子伦xxxx视频播放 |