Home
Letters to Editor
Domestic
World
Business & Trade
Culture & Science
Travel
Society
Government
Opinions
Policy Making in Depth
People
Investment
Life
Books/Reviews
News of This Week
Learning Chinese
Enron Sends Alarm Bells Ringing in China, Too

While the world was stunned by Enron's bankruptcy and the role of Arthur Andersen LLP in the fiasco, Chinese investors face the reality that irregularities occur not only in China's fledging accounting business, but also among foreign accounting firms based on Chinese land.

"I used to support the authority's decision to use big international accounting firms rather than domestic ones," said Cai Guangqiang, a 52-year-old investor in Shanghai. "But in light of the Enron-Andersen scandal, I think we should look at this decision carefully. It's not correct to have blind faith in big shots from foreign accounting firms."

Cai suffered a great loss from an investment in Yinguangxia, a listed company whose share price plummeted last year after it was found involved in stock fraud.

Heated debate

Zhongtianqin, a Shenzhen-based accounting firm, was found to have helped Yinguangxia fabricate profit reports to win a top performer position. Zhongtianqin's license has since been rebuked by the central government -- the Ministry of Finance in Beijing.

More than 60 listed company clients of Zhongtianqin, which was previously the largest and most renowned accounting firm in China, have had their reputations damaged because of the accounting firms' fraudulent actions related with Yinguangxia.

This scandal combined with several other stock fraud incidents led China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) to invite foreign accounting firms to audit listed companies.

Earlier last year, CSRC stipulated that listed financial companies needed to have their financial statements audited by one of the "Big 5" international accounting firms before disclosure. At the end of last year, the market watchdog went even further.

On December 31, CSRC released a provisional rule stating that, starting this year, public firms must use international accounting firms and make "supplementary" audit report before they issue new shares. The last decision sparked heated debate in the accounting community.

Cautious development

For the foreign players, especially the so-called "Big 5", it's a bitter-sweet new year gift.

The "Big 5" -- Andersen, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu (DTT), PricewaterhouseCoopers, KPMG and Ernst & Young - have all set up joint ventures in China.

"There have been quite a few domestic enterprises contacting us, including listed companies. And I think the same is true of the four other accounting firms," said Christopher Lu, head of DTT's Shanghai unit.

He shows caution rather than enthusiasm.

"We make very deliberate evaluations before we accept a new client," he said.

The "Big 5" are strong in international expertise, but working with Chinese enterprises is quite a different story.

According to Lu, the difference poses more challenge and audit risk for international accountants.

When the Big Five came to China a decade ago, they only served their existing multinational clients operating in China. However, in the last few years, they have witnessed a sharp surge in business from Chinese enterprises, especially the large State-owned enterprises, overseas-listed companies and private ventures.

DTT's China revenue increased by more than 20 percent in the last two years and about 30 percent of the revenue comes from domestic firms.

Challenges lie ahead

His view is shared by Professor Li Ruoshan, dean of the Accounting Department at Fudan University, and his primary concern is the potential misuse of the new rule.

All foreign accounting firms have their local partners, which means it is possible that the first audit report and the supplementary report are issued by the same auditor as long as the firm has two identities.

He also pointed out that the new rule is not in line with the World Trade Organization's national treatment principal.

Domestic accountants show even great concern to the new provision, saying it is unfair to them.

"The policy excludes all domestic accounting firms where the majority are honest and law-biding," complained a senior official with a leading Shanghai accounting firm, who preferred not to be identified.

Li believes it is a transitional measure as authorities hope experienced foreign accountants can reduce the number of fake accounts and guarantee the credibility of companies.

(China Daily February 5, 2002)

With Death, Enron is Even Greater Human Tragedy
FBI Investigate Document Shredding in Enron
Enron May Sell Its Business in China to Repay Debts
Enron Fires Andersen as Auditor
The Moral of Andersen’s Story
Ministry of Finance
Copyright © China Internet Information Center. All Rights Reserved
E-mail: webmaster@china.org.cn Tel: 86-10-68996214/15/16
主站蜘蛛池模板: 国产精彩对白综合视频| 精品无码成人久久久久久| 国产高清中文字幕| 一本久久精品一区二区| 日本免费看片在线播放| 亚州1区2区3区4区产品乱码2021| 波多野结衣和邻居老人| 免费视频淫片aa毛片| 老司机精品免费视频| 国产免费怕怕免费视频观看| 国产又污又爽又色的网站| 国产精品无圣光一区二区| 99久久人妻无码精品系列蜜桃| 好男人在线社区www| 一级毛片在线播放免费| 无人视频免费观看免费视频| 久久伊人男人的天堂网站| 晓青老师的丝袜系列txt下载| 亚洲国产av无码精品| 欧美第一页在线| 国产一国产一级毛片视频| 91视频综合网| 国产手机在线αⅴ片无码观看| 你懂的视频网站| 国产精品毛片va一区二区三区| 99久久99久久精品国产| 天堂在线www天堂中文在线| 久久久久亚洲av无码专区| 日韩精品欧美国产精品亚 | 大伊香蕉在线精品不卡视频| yy4080李崇端60集视频| 日韩免费在线观看| 亚州无吗黄瓜视频有直播的不| 欧美一级特黄乱妇高清视频 | 成人无码A级毛片免费| 亚洲一区精品无码| 欧美成人久久久| 公与2个熄乱理在线播放| 精品少妇人妻av一区二区| 啊轻点灬大ji巴太粗太长了h | 亚洲精品在线视频|